Rent a Car in Downtown Norr Bay Shore

North Bay Shore center is a community on Long Island in New York, although it's categorized under Florida in the system. The area is located in Suffolk County, approximately 70 km east of Manhattan and offers car rental for exploring Long Island's eastern parts. With a car from here you can reach the Hamptons in approximately 80 km and Fire Island National Seashore in 15 km south.

Bay Shore is known as the gateway to Fire Island, with ferries departing regularly to this car-free island. Along Main Street you'll find local restaurants and shops in a typical Long Island community. Rent a car early in the morning to avoid traffic queues to the Hamptons during summer weekends.

Choose a compact car – parking in Bay Shore center can be limited. Combine car rental with the Fire Island ferry for a complete day trip. How long does it take to drive from North Bay Shore to the Hamptons?

The Hamptons are located approximately 80–100 km east via Southern State Parkway and Montauk Highway, roughly 1–1.5 hours depending on traffic. Can I drive to Manhattan from North Bay Shore? Yes, Manhattan is approximately 70 km west, but expect 1.5–2 hours of driving in rush hour traffic via I-495 (Long Island Expressway).

Is there parking at the ferry terminals in Bay Shore? Yes, there is paid parking at Bay Shore Ferry Terminal, making it possible to combine car rental with a boat trip to Fire Island.

We compare prices from all major providers at North Bay Shore Center so you can see the total cost upfront — including insurance, fuel terms and any extras. Most bookings include free cancellation up to 48 hours before pickup, giving you flexibility if your plans change.