Car Rental in Bay Shore West

Bay Shore West on Long Island's south shore in Suffolk County has 1 car rental company and is the starting point for both beach life and commuting to New York City, 70 km to the west. The location on Sunrise Highway makes it easy to move along Long Island's south shore. Fire Island National Seashore is reached by ferry from Bay Shore Marina, just 2 km to the south.

Jones Beach State Park is 25 km to the west along Ocean Parkway. The LIRR station in Bay Shore connects to Penn Station in approximately 70 minutes. Combine a rental car with LIRR if you're heading into Manhattan – parking in NYC is expensive.

Refuel on Sunrise Highway rather than at highway exits for better prices. Avoid driving toward Manhattan during Friday afternoon rush hour. How do I get to Fire Island from Bay Shore?

Drive to Bay Shore Marina, 2 km to the south, and take the ferry – cars remain on the mainland. How long is the drive to JFK Airport? About 45 km to the west via Southern State Parkway, approximately 45–60 minutes depending on traffic.

Are there parking spaces at the rental location? Yes, the rental company on Sunrise Highway has parking on-site for pickup and return.

We compare prices from all major providers at Bay Shore West so you can see the total cost upfront - including insurance, fuel terms and any extras. Most bookings include free cancellation up to 48 hours before pickup, giving you flexibility if your plans change.